Overpronation, Flat Feet & High Arches: How Foot Mechanics Cause Knee Pain
|
|
Time to read 10 min
|
|
Time to read 10 min
Reviewed by James Maiorana, PT, DPT
James Maiorana is a licensed physical therapist with experience in orthopedic rehabilitation, sports biomechanics, functional movement, and injury recovery.
The feet are often underappreciated. Many people don't think about how important a role the feet play every day. Your feet are the base of your body, making initial contact with the floor or ground when you stand, walk, run and engage in various other types of movement. You rely heavily on your feet throughout the day to climb stairs, get in and out of your vehicle, do chores and much more. With every step that you take, your feet are constantly working to distribute your weight so that the rest of the body can evenly absorb the pressure and force.
If you have flat feet, the low or nonexistent arch can cause issues for some people. In some cases, the condition may alter weight and pressure distribution, which may lead to pain in your knees. But having flat feet doesn't always result in discomfort somewhere else in the body. Nor does it indicate that everyone with knee pain has a problem with their feet.
Humans have a lower- and upper-body kinetic chain. The lower-body segment comprises the feet, ankles, knees, hips and lower back. The sensations you feel throughout your lower body are directly impacted by the pressure absorption and movement patterns in your feet. This is why some healthcare professionals often study your gait and foot mechanics when assessing knee pain.
It can be helpful to understand the relationship between the feet, ankles, knees and hips during different types of movement and how they work together to support your body.
Healthy feet exhibit a natural inward rolling motion as you walk and run. This is called pronation and it's perfectly normal. However, when the feet roll too far inward, this is known as overpronation and it can be problematic for some people. If you have a mild case of overpronation, you may not notice much discomfort or any obvious issues with the way you move. When overpronation is more pronounced, you may notice symptoms. When the feet overpronate, they're often less capable of absorbing pressure and distributing weight. This issue doesn't just affect the feet. The lower legs may also turn inward and this can put pressure on the knees. If you are active and regularly engage in high-impact sports, your knees may suffer over time.
The medical term for high arches is pes planus. However, the condition of having little to no arch in your feet in most commonly known as fallen arches or flat feet. Without a natural curve to help evenly absorb pressure and distribute weight as you walk and run, the rest of the lower body may be exposed to additional stress, and this may lead to pain in other areas of the lower body, including the knees.
Having flat feet doesn't necessarily mean you're going to have knee pain, but research reflects a connection between foot posture and problem knees.
The medical term for high arches is pes cavus. It is the opposite of low arches or flat feet. Some people with high arches have very rigid feet that don't adapt well to changing movements. In this case, the arch never flattens to make contact with the ground when you run, stand or walk. The reduced contact with the ground may put more pressure on other areas of the foot, such as the heel and ball of the foot. If you keep noticing extra wear along the outer edges of your shoes, this may be a sign of a high arch. This is because people who have high arches tend to walk on the outsides of their feet.
Since a high arch can make the foot less flexible as it hits the ground, the effects can sometimes be felt in the lower leg or further up toward the knee. If you think about how many times your feet hit the ground as you run or jog, it becomes easier to understand how those repeated impacts can add up over time.
If you've had high arches since childhood and all of a sudden, you start experiencing knee pain, don't automatically assume that your arch shape is to blame. There are many other potential causes of knee pain. Your high arches also may be just one contributing factor.
Whether you experience periodic soreness or constant aching in your knees, never assume that your foot mechanics are the direct cause of your knee pain. For many people, there’s a combination of factors, ranging from activity level to muscle strength and joint health, that may be contributing to the discomfort. If your pain is preventing you from living your life normally, it’s best to make an appointment with your healthcare provider. Only a qualified health professional can make a diagnosis.
In order to determine the source of your knee pain and whether your foot mechanics may play a role, your doctor will likely take a look at the following factors:
Yes, insoles can help with knee pain related to foot mechanics. You might want to consider wearing insoles or orthotics if you believe your knee pain is the result of a foot mechanics issue. The right shoe insert may improve knee function in some people. Dr. Scholl's® Knee All-Day Pain Relief Orthotics are designed for different common types of knee pain: general knee pain, runner's knee and arthritic knee pain. These shock-absorbing orthotics take pressure off tender knees. Dr. Scholl's® Advanced Pain Relief Insoles can also be very beneficial for knee pain. These superior insoles feature exceptional padding and arch support to balance pressure over the entire lower body, reducing impacts that can travel up the legs and aggravate painful knees.
In some cases, mild and short-lived knee pain will resolve on its own with simple, home care measures. However, if your pain is moderate to severe and it doesn't improve after about two weeks, or it's preventing you from completing your typical daily tasks, it may be time to make an appointment with your healthcare provider.
It's also important to see your doctor right away if you began experiencing significant knee pain immediately following an accident. This is because you may have a serious injury necessitating medical treatment.
Your primary provider may refer you to a specialist, such as a podiatrist or orthopedist, depending on the findings of the initial examination and any relevant tests. They may also suggest a physical therapist. In many cases, conservative measures (such as insoles and orthotics) may be a part of a broader treatment plan.
Yes, flat feet can contribute to knee pain in some people. Without a natural arch to help evenly absorb pressure and distribute weight as you walk and run, the rest of the lower body may be exposed to additional stress. This altered weight distribution may lead to pain in the knees over time. However, having flat feet doesn't necessarily mean you will experience knee pain.
Overpronation occurs when your feet roll too far inward when you walk or run. While some inward rolling is natural and healthy, excessive pronation can reduce your feet's ability to absorb pressure and distribute weight properly. When the feet overpronate, the lower legs may also turn inward, putting additional pressure on the knees. This may be especially problematic if you're active and regularly engage in high-impact activities.
High arches (known medically as pes cavus) are often associated with rigid feet that don't adapt well to changing movements. The arch may never flatten to make full contact with the ground when you walk, stand or run. This reduced contact puts more pressure on other areas of the foot, such as the heel and ball. Since a high arch makes the foot less flexible as it hits the ground, the repeated impacts can sometimes be felt in the lower leg and knee over time.
The lower-body kinetic chain comprises the feet, ankles, knees, hips and lower back. All these parts work together to support your body during movement. The sensations you feel throughout your lower body are directly impacted by the pressure absorption and movement patterns in your feet. This is why a healthcare professional may want to observe your gait and foot mechanics when assessing knee pain. A problem in one part of the chain can affect other parts.
It can be difficult to tell if foot mechanics are causing your knee pain. To know for sure, schedule an appointment for an evaluation. Your doctor will likely assess several factors to determine if foot mechanics play a role in your knee pain. They may examine your walking or standing patterns, measure your arch height, evaluate the position of your hips, knees, feet and ankles, and ask about symptoms during particular activities. If you notice that your knees hurt worse after prolonged standing or walking, this may indicate foot involvement. Only a qualified healthcare professional can make a proper diagnosis.
Yes, insoles can help with knee pain related to foot mechanics in some cases. The right shoe insert may improve knee function by providing better arch support, cushioning and pressure distribution. This helps balance pressure over the entire lower body, reducing impacts that can travel up the legs and aggravate painful knees. Insoles and orthotics are often part of a broader treatment plan for knee pain.
You should make an appointment with your healthcare provider if your knee pain is moderate to severe and doesn't improve after about two weeks, or if it's preventing you from completing your typical daily tasks. See your doctor right away if you began experiencing significant knee pain immediately following an accident, as this may indicate a serious injury requiring medical treatment. Seek immediate medical care if your knee is deformed, you hear popping noises, or you have signs of an infection.
Yes, you can have knee pain without having foot problems. There are many potential causes of knee pain beyond foot mechanics. Activity level, muscle strength, joint health, previous injuries and underlying medical conditions can all contribute to knee discomfort. For many people, knee pain results from a combination of factors. Even if you have a foot condition, such as flat feet or high arches, it may be just one contributing factor rather than the sole cause of your pain.
Ankles provide stability and allow the body to pivot and change directions during movement. If there's a lack of ankle stability, other areas of the kinetic chain (including the knees) may be subjected to additional stress. Your doctor may assess ankle alignment and function when evaluating whether foot mechanics are contributing to your knee pain.
Yes, it’s normal for your feet to roll inward when you walk. Healthy feet exhibit a natural inward rolling motion called pronation as you walk and run, and this is perfectly normal. Pronation helps your feet absorb shock and adapt to different surfaces. The concern arises when your feet roll too far inward (a condition called overpronation). This can reduce your feet's ability to properly absorb pressure and distribute weight, potentially leading to knee pain over time. Overpronation can also cause the knees to twist inward, and this can lead to pain.
Sources:
[1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42518708/
[2] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21717597/
[3] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38456009/
[4] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26515886/
[5] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35721679/
[6] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11458233/
[7] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11209802/
[8] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5260548/
[9] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK587361/
[10] https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/high-arch-feet-pes-cavus
[11] https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/knock-knees-genu-valgum
[12] https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/body/24909-ankle-joint